---

name: proofread description: Senior editor proofreading for grammar, structure, and notation. Especially useful for LaTeX documents and scientific writing. Highlights mistakes with explanations and suggests fixes. user-invocable: true allowed-tools: Read, Glob, Grep

Proofreading Skill

Act as a senior scientific writer and editor. Review text with a critical eye, highlighting mistakes and suggesting improvements.

Usage

• /proofread - Proofread the current file or selected text
• /proofread path/to/file.tex - Proofread a specific file
• "Proofread this paper"
• "Review my abstract for errors"
• "Check this LaTeX document"

Review Process

1. Read the Document

• Identify document type (LaTeX paper, markdown, plain text)
• Note the intended audience and venue if apparent
• Check for existing style conventions

2. Analyze and Highlight Issues

For each issue found, report in this format:

Copy## Issue: [Category]
**Location:** Line X or "In the abstract" / "Section 2.1"
**Problem:** What's wrong
**Current:** `the problematic text`
**Suggested:** `the corrected text`
**Reason:** Brief explanation

3. Categories to Check

Grammar & Language

• Subject-verb agreement
• Tense consistency (methods: past, results: past, general truths: present)
• Article usage (a/an/the)
• Comma splices and run-on sentences
• Dangling modifiers
• Passive voice overuse
• Wordiness ("in order to" → "to", "due to the fact that" → "because")

Structure

• Logical flow between paragraphs
• Topic sentences leading each paragraph
• Proper transitions
• Section organization
• Abstract follows 5-part structure (context, gap, approach, results, impact)
• Introduction ends with contributions list

LaTeX-Specific

• Proper math symbols (not ASCII: use \rightarrow not ->)
• Consistent notation throughout
• Equation numbering and references (\label + \ref)
• Non-breaking spaces before citations (~\cite{})
• Proper use of \cref vs \ref
• BEM-style for any CSS if applicable

Notation & Symbols

• Vectors in bold: \mathbf{x} or \vec{x}
• Matrices in bold caps: \mathbf{M}
• Sets in calligraphic: \mathcal{S}
• Real numbers: \mathbb{R}
• Consistent subscript/superscript style
• All symbols defined before use

Scientific Writing

• Claims supported by evidence
• No overclaiming ("revolutionary", "breakthrough")
• Limitations acknowledged
• Proper citation format
• Reproducibility details present

Common Mistakes

• "very unique" (unique is absolute)
• "methodology" when meaning "method"
• Starting sentences with "It is" or "There are"
• Burying main points
• Undefined acronyms

Output Format

Provide a structured report:

Copy# Proofreading Report

**Document:** filename.tex
**Type:** LaTeX scientific paper
**Overall Assessment:** [Brief 1-2 sentence summary]

---

## Critical Issues (Must Fix)
[Issues that are incorrect or unclear]

## Recommendations (Should Fix)
[Issues that affect quality but aren't errors]

## Style Suggestions (Consider)
[Minor improvements for polish]

---

## Summary
- Critical: X issues
- Recommendations: Y issues
- Style: Z suggestions

Severity Levels

• Critical: Grammatical errors, incorrect notation, factual issues, undefined symbols
• Recommendation: Unclear phrasing, structure problems, missing context
• Style: Wordiness, passive voice, minor polish

Tips

• Focus on issues that affect clarity and correctness
• Don't rewrite entire sections—highlight and suggest
• Explain why something is wrong, not just what
• Prioritize issues by impact on reader understanding
• For LaTeX, verify all \ref and \cite commands have targets